The Hidden Costs of Dining Out: A Personal Encounter with Surcharges

After a fun family camping trip in the Yarra Valley, a favourite getaway spot, we decided to make a pit stop at a local brewery on our way back to Melbourne. As it was a public holiday in Australia, and the roads were busy, we were in need of some refreshment and a driver change before completing our journey home.

We chose a couple of pizzas and some drinks, and a beer for myself. As someone always intrigued by payment practices, I scanned the menu and, in small print at the bottom, noticed a 1.5% card surcharge. "Okay," I thought, "not too bad." Then, I spotted another detail in small print: an 18% public holiday charge, that seemed a bit high… However, when ordering, we were informed that the $15 pizza deal available on regular Mondays was not applicable due to the public holiday. Slightly less enthused but still content from our river adventures, we proceeded with our meal.

I requested a copy of the receipt—a habit of mine—and over my beer and pizza, I contemplated the numbers. Having previously owned and operated a hotel, I'm familiar with hospitality figures and norms. Realising I was drifting into analysis rather than enjoying my beer, I tucked the receipt into my pocket until this morning.

The Real Cost of Public Holiday Dining

The analysis of our receipt:

Cost Breakdown Amount Initial Bill $91.20 Public Holiday Surcharge (18%) $16.41 Subtotal $107.61 Card Service Fee (1.5%) $1.61 Total Paid $109.22

On a regular Monday, the same order would have cost:

Standard Monday Costs Amount Base Cost $71.40 Card Fee (1.5%) $1.07 Total $72.47

💡

The difference revealed a striking $36. 75, or a 51.48% increase in cost for dining on a public holiday.

Understanding Surcharges in Australia

In Australia, surcharges are additional fees that businesses impose to cover the costs associated with certain payment methods or operational factors, such as public holiday staffing. While these charges can be legitimate, they often catch consumers off guard, especially when not prominently displayed.

Card Payment Surcharges

In Australia, businesses are permitted to apply surcharges on card payments to recoup the costs charged by their financial service providers. However, these surcharges must reflect the actual cost incurred and not be used as a profit-making tool. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) enforces regulations to prevent excessive surcharging. For instance, if a business's cost of processing a Visa or MasterCard payment is 1.5%, it cannot impose a surcharge higher than that percentage.

Public Holiday and Weekend Surcharges

Beyond payment method surcharges, many Australian hospitality venues impose additional charges on weekends and public holidays. These surcharges are intended to offset the higher wages mandated by law for staff working during these times. According to Fair Work Australia, hospitality staff receive increased pay rates on Sundays and public holidays, justifying the application of such surcharges by businesses.

However, the implementation of these surcharges has been a topic of debate. While some consumers view these surcharges as unjustified, industry representatives argue they are necessary to cover increased operational costs.

Disclosure Requirements in Victoria

In Victoria, businesses are required to display surcharge information prominently to ensure consumers are well-informed before making a purchase. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) stipulates that if a restaurant or café applies a surcharge on certain days, such as weekends or public holidays, they must include a statement on the menu indicating the percentage of the surcharge and the specific days it applies.

💡

This statement must be at least as prominent as the most prominent price on the menu. For example, if the menu lists prices in bold or a larger font, the surcharge information must be displayed in a similar manner to ensure visibility. This regulation aims to prevent consumers from being misled about the total cost of their meal and ensures that surcharge information is not hidden in fine print.

Future of Australian Payment Surcharges

The landscape of surcharging in Australia is continually evolving. Regulatory bodies like the ACCC are actively monitoring and adjusting guidelines to ensure fair practices. Recent discussions have focused on the potential banning of debit card surcharges by January 1, 2026, reflecting a move towards more consumer-friendly payment systems.

For businesses, staying updated on regulatory changes and maintaining transparent practices is crucial. For consumers, increased awareness and proactive engagement can lead to more satisfactory dining and shopping experiences.

Conclusion

My experience at the brewery served as a personal reminder of the importance of transparency and awareness regarding surcharges. While businesses have legitimate reasons for imposing certain fees, clear communication is essential to maintain trust and satisfaction. As consumers, staying informed and vigilant can help navigate these additional costs, ensuring that our dining

Enjoyed this article?

We regularly publish insights on payment strategy, risk, and governance.
You will find more articles here.

Let’s talk if you think Payment Matters could be the right fit for your needs. Reach out to discuss how we can support your organisation.
paymentmatters.com.au